
I’m married to a woman who 1) enjoys musicals and 2) has a thing for Pierce Brosnan. So when I saw the ads for Mamma Mia my immediate thought was, “Damn you, Hollywood! Damn you straight to hell!” Somehow I avoided having to see this in the theater, but then the DVD came out around Christmas and, long story short, I’ve now sat through the musical comedy featuring the music of ABBA. As a sort of (what I hope is) therapeutic cleansing, I’m offering up this review, of sorts, which perhaps will give me back the hour and 40 minutes spent listening to bubblegum pop sung and danced to by James Bond and the White Witch from Chronicles of Narnia [ed.: that wasn't Meryl Streep]. OK, then Cruella De Vil [ed.: that was Glenn Close]. Really? [ed.: yep].
01:13 The singing begins. Sophie’s (Amanda Seyfried) cute, at least. Letters are sent off to three possible dads as she wants to know who her father is, and there are three suspects. What, is her mom some sort of cat?
02:32: All three men (Pierce Brosnan, Colin Firth, and Stellan Skarsgard) are apparently incredibly wealthy. How convenient.
4:12: Sophie spills the beans to her friends about her mom’s diary (kept while pregnant with Sophie). Mom’s…how to put this?…a slut. Hey, if this movie were centered around a guy who slept with three women during a summer, I’d make the same comment. Only I’d use the words “lucky bastard.”
5:01: The first actual song, “Honey Honey” is sung by Seyfried and her friends. They’re much too excited about the fact that they’re singing about Sophie’s mom’s sexual exploits.
6:50: Meryl Streep shows up, looking like that actress from Bridges of Madison County [ed.: that WAS her, idiot].
7:50: The dilemma is posed: who’s Sophie’s dad? The invites are part of a grand plan of Sophie’s to, apparently, get a look at the men and pick Pierce Brosnan for her dad (yeah, like Skarsgard stands a chance).
9:25: Meryl Streep’s best friends show up for the wedding:

Looks like a good time to go get some snacks. I thought Walter’s character was Streep’s mom, but I was wrong.
10:25: The fiance (Dominic Cooper) shows up. No singing as he’s about to get married.
12:13: Apparently, it’s a rule that girlfriends who have not seen each other in a while must scream excitedly in octaves normally reserved for dog whistles. And, yes, Streep and her friends were apparently in a 70s singing group. Oh, joy.
14:30: Back to the suspected dads – they discuss how they know Donna (Streep), but the fact that each biblically knew her isn’t raised.
16:45: A legend about a fountain beneath the hotel/spa that Streep’s character (Donna) owns is mentioned (Aphrodite’s fountain). I bet that’s important.
17:30: “Money, Money” – Meryl Streep’s first song. First bathroom break.
20:46: Sex talk from Streep, Walters, and Baranski, God help me. Meanwhile, Sophie takes the dads to a room and tells them their presence is a surprise for her mom, and to keep it a secret. This secret lasts, oh, about 1 minute.
26:21: Streep sees her three former beaus and the title song is sung. She’s apparently still carrying a torch, but for which one? The suspense is killing me. Oh, wait, that’s not suspense, that’s ABBA.
31:00: The virile young black bartender has the hots for Baranski’s character. Sure he does. Give that man an Oscar!
32:30: Third song. Streep, Baranski and Walters. Shortly thereafter, Streep admits she’s a slut, and that she’s going to hell for it. Okay, maybe not that last part.
36:52: In an attempt to wrest control of the song from cross-dressing contests, “Dancing Queen” is interpreted here as a celebration of womanhood. I don’t know, I think it works better as an ode to drag. And, hell, they even trotted out Milton Berle as a back-up singer! Waitaminute, oops, no, that’s Julie Walters.
41:10: In what could have been a pretty creepy scene, Sophie hangs out with her three dads on Skarsgard’s boat as they sing about banging her mom (the song’s “Our Last Summer” for those of you keeping score). Skarsgard’s singing is about like you’d expect.
45:00: Sophie’s fiance sees her dive from the boat and confronts her about spending time with three strange men (one who looks like James Bond) for the past two hours, culminating in his calling off the wedding. At least that’s what should have happened.
45:38: Ah, I thought the cigar Sky (yep, that’s the fiance’s name) was holding was a phallic symbol, but instead it’s just there to make the song’s lyrics make sense (“Lay All Your Love on Me”).
47:18: In a twist worthy of Top Gun, dancing men in speedos come out of the water and “rescue” Sky from his woman.
48:10: Streep and her friends relive their glory years singing for her daughter’s bachelorette party (“Super Trouper” – no, it has nothing to do with stoned highway patrolmen).
50:00: If I read the back of the DVD right, I’ve got another hour to go. Time for a beer.
50: 50: The dads arrive at the bachelorette party.
51: 40: “Give me a Man After Midnight” starts up – hey, this scene has possibilities. The somewhat scantily-clad girls take Firth and Skarsgard and start dancing with them, pulling at their clothes.
51:55: Nevermind, cut to Streep and her friends ranting. Brosnan shows up.
54:15: Colin Firth, for some reason, wants to escape being pawed at by the young women. Skarsgard is living it up, though.
55:20: Skarsgard manages to figure the secret out first. He runs like hell.
56:00: Sophie catches him and coerces him to walk her down the aisle.
Those past two comments might not be entirely accurate.
56:50: Sky and his band of gay friends have apparently left their party and come to crash the girls’ party. Dancing ensues (“Voulez Vous”).
58:18: Brosnan tells Sophie he’s her dad and tells her he’ll give her away.
58:50: Now Firth believes he’s her dad, too, and wants to give her away. There hasn’t been so many men trying to give away something that doesn’t quite belong to them since 1947.
1:02:29: In a questionable career move, Skarsgard shows his bare ass.
1:06:12: Brosnan confronts Streep about their past and what they lost. For some reason, Brosnan is trying to sing with an Italian accent (“S.O.S”).
1:08:50: Young black bartender continues to chase Baranski, and she mocks him in song (“Does Your Mother”). The “mistake last night” referred to was apparently the singing and dancing number at the bachelorette party.
1:15:30: “Slipping Through My Fingers” could actually be a bit of a tear-jerker if you have a daughter. If you don’t, then fuck you, it’s just allergies.
1:21:25: Meryl Streep singing yet another song about how she and Brosnan can’t get the time back…maybe. I’m not quite sure how “Winner Takes it All” fits in, but it seems like the big emotionally climactic moment. I know this because waves are crashing and Streep’s running around waving her arms dramatically.
1:25: 43: The wedding is finally here. End in sight.
1:29:20: The wedding is interrupted as everyone tries to figure out who Sophie’s dad is; Colin Firth attempts to take himself out of the running by announcing he is gay. Firth, you’re one brilliant bastard.
1:29:58: Because Mamma Mia‘s a comedy, they can’t end with a young couple marrying. So Brosnan takes one for the team and proposes to Streep (“I Do, I Do, I Do”).
1:32:05: In a shameless plug for Viagra, Brosnan sings a song exclaiming that he and Streep are not too old for sex (“When All is Said and Done”).
1:34:45: Skarsgard is serenaded by Walters (“Take a Chance on Me”) because otherwise both have been forgotten by this point. Firth, desperate not to have to pay for Sophie’s wedding, keeps up the gay act.
1:37:08: The fountain of Aphrodite erupts, showering all the wedding guests – a sexual metaphor if I ever saw one (and I knew that early, seemingly pointless reference had some significance); dancing ensues.
The credits roll as the cast dress up in funky outfits and sing “Dancing Queen”, seemingly recognizing the futility in not associating that song with drag. And as the movie’s over, this review is done, and I believe I have successfully exorcised my ABBA-induced demons.
Now if I could only take back seeing Stellan Skarsgard’s ass.